Best Years In Film History
We can only draft films released during the 10 best film years in US history. We'd have to come up with some kind of agreed list of years, of course, but off the top of my head we got 1939, 1946, 2007, 1999, 1971, 1989. Could be fun to see what would go first, Stagecoach or Do The Right Thing.
As detailed in the Sci-Fi draft discussion thread. It'd be totally nuts but a lot of fun. The downside is that all the strategy and machinations would probably fall to the wayside, as people's lists would be a lot more personal than normal, but the discussion would be great.
Oscar Winners and Nominees
This would maybe have less outside the box picks than most, but as long as the films can have won/been nominated for anything, there can still be some surprises. Mondo Cane would be eligible!
Mutant films. To be eligible, it's got to be a melding of two genres. Lot of fun arguments and creative interpretations to be had here. I think comedy/dramas would have to be disqualified, unless a particularly compelling argument can be made.